“Hold on,” Mike said, his pragmatic side taking over. “Let’s figure this out first. That container has been in the water for years. It might have been written off as a loss long ago.” Under maritime law, “finds” can be complicated. If property is truly abandoned or the owner is unknown, the finder can sometimes claim a significant portion of the value, but there are rules to follow.
The next day, Mike returned to the island with a flashlight. He counted 48 crates, each weighing about 100 pounds. A quick calculation made his head spin: nearly 5,000 pounds of vanilla. At a conservative market price, that was over a million dollars. But the joy was tempered by a growing sense of unease. A cargo this valuable doesn’t just vanish without someone looking for it.
He photographed every marking. Some crates had French labels: *Vanilla Bourbon de Madagascar*. A week later, a stranger pulled into Fisher’s Cove in a blacked-out Chevy Suburban with out-of-state plates. The man, Victor Vance, introduced himself as a private investigator from Seattle. Vance was in his fifties, dressed in a sharp charcoal suit that looked out of place in a fishing village, with a pair of cold, observant eyes.
He spoke with a polite but firm tone. His business card read: *Victor Vance, Asset Recovery Specialist.* “I’m looking for lost property,” he told the locals at the diner. “Three years ago, during a storm, several containers were lost off the freighter *Northern Star*. One of them contained a very specific, very valuable shipment of spices.”
A major hurricane had indeed swept through the coast back in 2016, causing massive shipping losses. It was a plausible story. Vance went from dock to dock, offering a $10,000 reward for any information. He showed photos of a container that looked identical to the one Mike had found. Eventually, he found Mike at the marina. “Mr. Rollins?” Vance asked, leaning against the railing. “I hear you’re one of the few guys who still heads out to the outer islands. Seen anything unusual lately? Metal debris? Shipping crates?”
