Something inside Susan snapped at that moment. Quietly, without a sound, but irrevocably, like a string pulled too tight. The next morning, she drove to the assisted living facility without calling first. Eleanor lived in a bright, tidy room with a large window overlooking a manicured garden. It wasn’t depressing, but dignified, as she liked to say, free of the institutional gloom of state-run places. She was sitting in an armchair with a book, her glasses perched on the end of her nose. The moment she saw Susan, she knew. “Tell me,” she said instead of a greeting, setting her book on the table and taking off her glasses. “Tell me everything, from the beginning.”
Susan told her everything, holding nothing back: the missing cello, the hole for the pool, her parents’ words about a “family heirloom,” their casual “Lily will be fine,” and their final warning, “not a word to your grandmother.” Eleanor listened without interrupting, without gasping or wringing her hands. Her face remained still, but the slight tightening of her fingers on the armrest betrayed her inner tension. “And Lily? How is she?” “She asked… if maybe she was the one at fault. If she’d done something to offend you, and that’s why…”
Eleanor’s expression changed. Not to fury or rage, but to a kind of calm, clear certainty that unnerved Susan. “People get funny when money’s involved,” her grandmother said slowly, weighing each word. “Even the closest family. Especially the closest family. It seems some of them are my own daughter and granddaughter. Susan, when did you last see the paperwork for the cello?”
“The paperwork?” Susan didn’t immediately understand. “The photos, the appraisal, the insurance policy. You remember, I showed you the folder. Do you have pictures of the construction? Anything showing the work started right after I moved here?” Susan nodded numbly, confused by the questions. She wanted to call the police, file a report, cause a scene. “Hold on,” Eleanor raised a hand, stopping her. “Don’t be hasty. I know what I’m doing. I’ve been preparing for this.”
She paused, looking out the window at the blooming apple trees in the garden, then turned back to her granddaughter. Her voice was calm and businesslike, the tone of someone discussing a settled matter. “The cello was legally gifted to Lily. The deed of gift was notarized. Arthur Hayes—you remember him? He’s an old family friend, knew your grandfather. They had no right to sell it. It’s the property of a minor, and only you, as her mother and legal guardian, can make decisions about it.”
Eleanor picked up her phone from the nightstand, dialed a number, and had a brief conversation. Susan only caught the words “Arthur” and “just as we discussed,” before she hung up. “I’ll handle this. No screaming, no drama.” She squeezed Susan’s hand—her fingers were dry but surprisingly strong. “Lily will get her cello back, because they never had the right to sell it. It’s not a family heirloom; it’s her property, established by law. Don’t you worry, sweetheart. I saw something like this coming when I drew up the papers. The wheels are in motion, Susan. Everything will be set right.”
Saturday was hot and humid—a typical Southern summer day when the asphalt melts and all you want to do is lie in the shade until fall. Lily wore her swimsuit under her sundress. At eleven, hope is a stubborn thing, not yet broken by life. Cars lined the street, and the backyard was crowded with guests—aunts, uncles, cousins, neighbors—the kind of crowd the family loved to gather, because it made them feel important and successful. The yard looked like a page from a lifestyle magazine: blue water shimmered in the sun, casting reflections on the guests’ faces, and the new stone patio gleamed.
Mason was splashing in the water, and Amelia was floating on an inflatable ring, wearing children’s sunglasses like a tiny movie star. Karen held a glass of rosé and laughed loudly at every joke, Kevin hovered by the grill playing the part of host and provider, and Patricia stood at the center of it all, the matriarch whose decisions had just been validated by a sparkling blue pool. When Susan and Lily walked through the gate, Lily’s gaze swept over the pool, the gazebo, the new lounge chairs and umbrellas—everything her cello, her music, her connection to her great-grandmother had become. She swallowed hard, and Susan put a hand on her shoulder, feeling the tense muscles under the thin fabric of her dress.
“Where’s Eleanor?” one of the guests asked, looking around. “Is the lady of the house joining the party?” Patricia’s smile became a little tighter, a little less genuine. “Mom’s at her new place. She’s doing well there. She’s not really one for big parties anymore.” At that moment, the gate clicked open, and in walked Eleanor Vance. Not with a cane, not stooped over, not looking like a frail old woman who’d been shipped off to a nursing home. She was wearing a light blouse and summer slacks, her calm, composed expression creating a strange sense of coolness in the middle of the July heat, in the middle of this suffocating celebration of someone else’s good fortune.
Comments are closed.