But that “thank you” sounded like a goodbye. A goodbye to her faith in justice, in the law, in the men in uniform. She walked out of the office, down the hallway, and out into the street. She took a deep breath. The world hadn’t changed. The sun was still shining, people were still rushing about.
But she had changed. The cold ball in her chest had turned to ice. She was no longer a victim looking for help. She was a judge who had just realized that justice would have to be served by her own hands.
The next few days were a gray blur of hospital smells, the squeak of gurneys, and silence. Ellen barely left the hospital, only going home to shower before rushing back. She sat by Sarah’s bed for hours. She held her limp hand and talked, and talked, and talked.
She told her about little things—the neighbors, the weather, she read her favorite poems. She did it in a desperate, irrational hope that her voice could pierce the fog surrounding her daughter’s mind, reaching the real Sarah who was still in there, locked inside that broken body.
But Sarah didn’t answer. Her gaze remained fixed on the ceiling. Sometimes her fingers would twitch in Ellen’s hand, and Ellen’s heart would leap with hope, but it was just a reflex.
The doctor, the same tired man from the first night, just shook his head. Physically, he said, she was stable. She would live. Но as for her mind—the head injury was severe. And the psychological shock? Medicine was powerless there. They had done all they could. Now, they could only wait.
On the fourth day, Ellen got a call. They didn’t have a phone in the apartment, so her neighbor called her to the hall. It was Detective Miller. His voice was hesitant, muffled. He asked her to come to the station, saying they had… results.
Same hallway, same office. Miller sat at his desk looking like he’d aged five years. There were dark circles under his eyes, and he avoided her gaze, shuffling papers. The tension in the air was thick.
“Come in, Mrs. Miller,” he said without looking up.
Ellen sat down. Her heart beat with a dull, anxious thud. What would he say? Did they find them? Did they arrest them?
“The medical examiner’s report came back,” he said finally, and there was a note in his voice that made Ellen go cold. It was the sound of shame.
He slowly pushed an official form with a blue seal toward her. Ellen took it. Her hands shook. She started reading. First came the medical terms: hematomas, abrasions, soft tissue damage. Then she reached the final line. The conclusion.
A few words typed in a dry, soulless font: “Injuries consistent with a fall down stairs while in a state of intoxication.” Ellen read the phrase. Again. And again. The letters danced, but the meaning wouldn’t sink in.
A fall. Down stairs. Intoxication. It was so grotesque, so absurd, that for a moment she thought she was losing her mind. That it was a mistake, a typo. Her Sarah, who barely touched a glass of punch. Stairs. What stairs were in the middle of the park?
She slowly looked up at the detective. He was still staring at the desk. His cheeks were flushed red.
“What is this?” she asked. Her voice was a whisper.
“It’s the official conclusion,” Miller muttered. “Signed by the examiner. We… we have to accept it.”
“What stairs?” Ellen asked again, her voice still low.
Miller was silent. He couldn’t answer. Because there was no answer. There was only a blatant, shameless, powerful lie. In that moment, everything clicked for Ellen. Commissioner Sterling’s visit. His contemptuous look. His words about “looking for trouble.” This wasn’t a mistake. This was a sentence. A sentence passed not on her daughter, but on her. A sentence on her attempt to find the truth.
“Alcohol was found in your daughter’s blood,” Miller added, as if apologizing. “It confirms…”
“She had one glass of punch at graduation,” Ellen interrupted, her voice like ice. “One glass. With the whole class. And that’s now called ‘intoxication’?”
She stared at him. She saw not an officer of the law, but a small, frightened boy who feared his boss more than his own conscience. She didn’t even feel sorry for him. She felt nothing but cold.
“So, there’s no case?” she asked. It wasn’t a question; it was a fact.
“Technically, there’s no crime,” Miller forced out, still not looking at her. “An accident.”
Ellen stood up. She carefully placed the paper on the edge of the desk. She didn’t scream, she didn’t cry, she didn’t make a scene. She was absolutely calm. And that calmness was more terrifying than any scream. She looked at the American flag in the corner, then at the slumped figure of the detective.
“I understand,” she said. “Thank you for your work.”
She turned and walked out, leaving him alone with his shame. She walked down the hallway, down the stairs, and out into the street. For the first time in days, she knew exactly what she was going to do. The system had shown its face. The doctors, the examiners, the police—they were all just cogs in a machine designed to protect men like Sterling and Taylor from women like her and Sarah.
A wall had risen in front of her. And she realized that trying to knock it down with her head was useless. This wall couldn’t be stormed. It had to be bypassed. And she would strike from the side they least expected.
Hope is a strange thing. Even when reason says it’s gone, the heart clings to the thinnest thread. Despite the humiliation at the station, a tiny ember still glowed in Ellen’s soul. That ember was Lily, Sarah’s best friend.
Ellen knew the girls had been inseparable all night. If anyone had seen anything, if anyone knew a detail that could shatter the lie about the stairs, it was Lily. Finding her was easy; they lived in the same neighborhood.
Ellen walked to the familiar apartment building and went to the third floor. Lily’s mother opened the door—a kind woman who always gave Sarah cookies. Seeing Ellen, she gasped, her face immediately filling with sympathy.
“Ellen, oh my god, come in! I heard. It’s just terrible! How is Sarah? We’ve been so worried!”
In the small living room sat Lily. Seeing Sarah’s mother, she jumped up, her eyes filling with tears.
“Mrs. Miller!”
Ellen hugged the shaking girl. For the first time in days, someone shared her grief sincerely.
“Lily, honey, I’m sorry to just show up,” Ellen said softly, pulling back to look the girl in the eyes. “I need your help. You were with Sarah until the end, right?”
Lily nodded, wiping her eyes.
“Yes, we danced, then we went out for air. We said goodbye at the school gates. I saw her start walking home. And then…”
Comments are closed.