Mike Larson bought a fixer-upper in the fading town of Oak Creek. Five acres of land, a sturdy cabin, and total silence. It was a retiree’s dream. But when he hired a crew to clean out the old stone well, they climbed back out a minute later, pale as sheets.
The foreman’s hands were shaking as he dialed 911. One of the workers had to sit down, looking like he was about to lose his lunch. What lay at the bottom of that well wasn’t rocks or debris. It was a discovery that would haunt the entire county.
Three months ago, Mike had stumbled across the listing. A house and land in rural Pennsylvania, near the Appalachian foothills. Five acres for $45,000. In the city, that wouldn’t even buy you a parking spot.
Mike called the realtor without much hope, expecting a total wreck.
— “What’s the condition?”
— “Solid bones. Built by the owner’s grandfather.”
It had been sitting empty for thirty years, but it hadn’t fallen down. Why so cheap? The town was dying. Maybe a dozen residents left in the whole area. No jobs, no local grocery store. Who would want it? Mike did. At 54, he was burnt out. Tired of the city, tired of the rat race. He’d sold his small business, finalized a divorce, and his kids were grown. He just wanted some peace and quiet.
He went to see it. Oak Creek was fading gracefully. Rolling hills, thick woods, and meadows stretching to the horizon. The neighboring houses were sagging and overgrown, but picturesque in a rustic way. The old Miller house stood on the edge of town. A large cabin made of darkened timber. The roof was dipping and the porch was soft, but it was built to last.
The seller, an heir living in the city, met him at the gate.
— “Take a look around. I haven’t been here since I was a kid.”
Mike walked through the rooms. Dust, cobwebs, and that heavy scent of an old house. But the walls were straight and the fireplace was intact. It had potential. He stepped out into the backyard. A shed, a small barn, and the well. An old stone well with a heavy wooden cover. Mike slid it aside and peered in. Pitch black. Deep.
He couldn’t see any water.
— “It’s dry,” the seller said. “Went dry years ago. My grandfather used to complain about it.”
— “Can it be restored?”
— “Hard to say. You’re probably better off drilling a new one.”
Mike nodded and slid the cover back. He bought the place that day, cash. He didn’t even haggle. He moved in that May. The first month was all about the basics: roof, windows, doors. He hired a local crew from the next county over—a guy named Rick and two helpers.
They worked fast and knew their stuff. By June, the house felt alive again. Fresh paint, sanded floors. The fireplace was humming. Mike looked at the progress and felt a rare sense of accomplishment. A new life, a fresh start.
Then there was the water issue. Drilling a new well was expensive and would take weeks. But the old one was right there. Maybe it wasn’t dry; maybe it was just clogged with silt. He called Rick.
— “Can you guys clean out that old well?”
— “We can take a look.”
— “How deep is it?”
— “Looks like about 35 or 40 feet.”
— “We can handle that.”
— “When?”
— “Tomorrow morning.”
The next morning was bright and sunny. Rick arrived with his gear—ropes, buckets, a ladder, and heavy-duty flashlights.
— “Alright,” Rick said. “Sam’s going down to scout it out. Then we’ll see what we’re dealing with.”
Sam, a lean young guy, put on a hard hat with a headlamp and harnessed himself to the rope.
— “Ready?”
— “Ready.”
He descended slowly, carefully. Mike and Rick held the safety line, bracing themselves. Sam’s voice echoed up, muffled by the stone walls.
— “How’s it looking down there?”
— “About 40 feet. I’m almost at the bottom.”
Then, silence.
— “Sam!” Rick shouted. “What do you see?”
No answer.
— “Sam!”
A voice came back, thin and strained.
— “Pull me up. Pull me up right now. Fast!”
They hauled him up in record time. When Sam scrambled out, Mike stepped back. The kid was white. Not just pale—ghostly. His lips were trembling, his eyes wide and unfocused.
— “What is it?” Rick asked.
Sam turned toward the trees and lost his breakfast. Rick looked at Mike, grabbed a high-powered flashlight, and leaned over the well. He stared down for a long time, silent. When he stood up, his face was just as drained.
— “Mike,” he said quietly. “Call the police.”
— “What’s down there?”
— “Bones. Human bones. A lot of them.”
The State Police arrived two hours later. Two cruisers, then a forensics van. The lead investigator, a sharp-eyed man in a suit, introduced himself.
— “Detective Henderson.”
— “Mike Larson. I just bought the place.”
— “How long ago?”
— “Three months.”
— “Have you used the well?”
— “No. We just opened it today for the first time.”
Henderson nodded. He walked to the well, shone his light down, and studied the depths. He stepped away and made a quiet, brief phone call. He returned five minutes later.
— “The crime lab and the coroner are on their way. We’re taping off the property. You’ll need to find a place to stay for a few days.”
— “Where am I supposed to go?”
— “A motel in the next town would be best. We need this area clear.”
Mike looked at the well, then at the officers stretching yellow tape across his yard.
— “How many are down there?”
Henderson paused.
— “It’s a lot, Mr. Larson.”
By evening, the site was a hive of activity. Three more vans, a dozen people. They set up tents and floodlights. They worked through the night under the glare of portable generators.
Mike sat on the porch of Mrs. Gable, his only neighbor within half a mile. He sipped a coffee, watching the lights at his house.
— “What did they find, Mike?” Mrs. Gable asked.
— “Bones.”
— “Whose?”
Comments are closed.